Salad Dressings

This dressing from Wishbone used to be called “Just 2 Good” but it is not.  This dressing has more of a sweet taste than others based on Dijon mustard. This taste is more like a honey mustard dressing because there is no “zip” to it. The taste is not bad just kind of weak.  It seemed that I had to use more to be able to taste the dressing or it would be overpowered by even a weak salad.

The calories in this dressing are not too bad (50) and fat calories = 20 but as I mentioned above I tended to add more than the proper serving size in order to be able to taste the dressing.  The ingredient list is pretty much on par with the other however in the list of leading ingredients are high fructose corn syrup, sugar and honey. These are 3 of the top 6 ingredients and lead to the 6g of sugars and 8g total carbs.

This dressing is a good choice if you like a sweet tasting honey Dijon dressing. It is not as sweet as a Catalina type dressing but more than usual for a Dijon dressing. The sodium of not too bad (250 mg/10%) and if you can stick to the serving size it is fairly good on calories.

Taste Rating = 5 bottles

Overall Rating = 5 bottles

Style Category = Honey Mustard

Fat Category = low fat

Calorie Category = low calorie

Nutritional Category = none

Sodium Category = med low

The advertising statement for this dressing claims - “Finally…a lite dressing full of flavor with all the zing of our original Honey Mustard. One of our favorites!” I cannot really disagree with this statement since I haven’t tried their original Honey Mustard but I would not say it has much “zing”. The smell is not very strong and the taste is similar. It has a good flavor that is not overpowering but a little on the sweet side rather than sharp or spicy.

This dressing has more fat, carbs and sugars compared to many other “light” dressing and this is reflected in the starting ingredient, high fructose sugar. That is followed by water, cider vinegar, vegetable oil (contains soy or canola oil), dry buttermilk, Dijon mustard (back mustard seeds, vinegar, white wine, salt spices), honey, salt, mustard (mustard seeds, vinegar, salt, spices), mustard powder, lemon juice concentrate, mustard seed, xanthan gum, potassium sorbate (preservative), caramel color, dry onion and dry garlic. This does indicate that mustard is definitely in this dressing since it is mentioned several times in the list of ingredients but the taste is not as sharp as you would think.

As I mentioned earlier, this dressing is not as “lite” as some others. The total fat is 5g (7%) with 0.5 g of saturated fat (4%) and total carbs = 9g (3%) and 9g of sugar. Also the sodium content is high with 300mg (13%). Apart from this the dressing is pleasant, sweet but not overpowering. If it had fewer fat and calories I would not object to using this dressing frequently. I compares fairly well again the Newman’s Own Light Honey Mustard dressing but is not as tangy or strong-tasting.

Taste Rating = 7

Overall Rating = 6

Style Category = Honey Mustard

Fat Category = low

Calorie Category = med calorie

Nutritional Category = none

Sodium Category = med

In my book this is the “gold standard” by which all other salad dressings are judged. This has been my favorite dressing since the first time I tasted it around 2 years ago. I have eaten it, on the average, of three times a week since then and I’m still not tired of it. I, for one, am amazed by this. I can’t imagine eating anything else that frequently and not being ready to gag if I had to eat it again.

The smell is not very strong upon sniffing the open bottle. It is slightly reminiscent of Dijon mustard although that is not one of the ingredients in it but it does list “Creole mustard” as one. The taste, however, is very strong for a “light” dressing. The first taste every time causes me to pucker just a little bit because of the tartness of it. The taste does not get weaker but stays just a strong throughout the salad but you kind of get used to this tartness. This dressing is fairly thick and has small bits of something dark in it that I can’t identify by reading the ingredients on the label. It looks something like small brown seeds. It could be mustard seeds but the label states that it only contains “ground mustard seed”.

The statistics on the label compares it to regular honey mustard dressing. It states that it has “60% Less Fat and 45% Fewer Calories than Regular Honey Mustard Dressing”. It is not extremely low-fat (4 grams vs. 11 grams) and not extremely low calorie (70 calories vs. 126 calories) or sugar-free (5 grams). The list of ingredients does not contain many surprises; water, Creole mustard (ground mustard seed, distilled vinegar, salt), cider vinegar, sugar, vegetable oil (soybean oil and/or canola oil), maltodextrin, hone, contains 2% or less of : salt, buttermilk solids (milk), spice, xanthan gum, lemon juice concentrate, dried onion, dried garlic. It also has an expiration date on the bottle and I guess this helps to insure freshness but I wouldn’t think it would spoil or get weaker while sealed in the bottle.

As I stated earlier – this is my favorite dressing and until I find a lower-calorie offering with as much taste I’m going to stick with this. As a bonus their web site tell us that “Newman’s Own, Inc. makes no gift to charity, but Paul Newman, who receives all the profits and royalties from Newman’s Own, Inc., distributes all of that personally to the charities of his choice. Since the inception of the company, it is our understanding that the total amount of those gifts to charity has been approximately $200 million.”

Rating = 9

Style Category = Honey Mustard

Fat Category = fat free

Calorie Category = low calorie

Nutritional Category = none

Sodium Category = high

Zero calories, zero fat, zero sugar…. Sounds like a dream come true, doesn’t it? How bad could it be? With no bad stuff in it I thought it would be possible to just drink it like water and pour as much on your salad as you liked. Anyone conscious of their weight or health would have to pay attention to this dressing. With much anticipation I tried this Honey Dijon Vinaigrette from Walden Farms.

I smelled the open bottle first. The smell was reminiscent of eggs and mayonnaise (notice I said “reminiscent” since neither is contained in this dressing). My first taste was from sticking my finger in the bottle and putting it to my lips. Not too bad I thought; very weak but not offensive. I tried it on a tossed salad and when I got through eating I thought – what was the use of that? This is pretty much the conclusion I came to – why bother? The dressing is creamy, but it is watery and thin. You get finished eating it and can’t remember what you were eating. There is almost no taste at all. There is no after-taste and that is good but that’s about the best you can say about it. I keep going back to try it again by tasting the dressing alone and get the same impression- there is a hint (just a hint) of Dijon mustard but that is all. It is so weak the taste is overwhelmed by a bland lettuce like iceberg. It keeps your salad from being dry but that is about all.

The list of ingredients should clue you in to the taste of this dressing: “Purified Triple Filtered Water” is the main ingredient followed by apple cider vinegar, white vinegar, Dijon mustard, cellulose gel, onion, garlic, beta carotene, xanthan gum, propylene glycol alginate, sodium benzoate, food color and sucralose. Not too much to object to here. Don’t expect to get many vitamins or minerals from the dressing either because there are none supplied in this product. Their Web site is not informative; it is mainly a shopping site where you can order salad dressing and other of their products. It took me a few clicks to actually find any information about the dressings other than a couple of videos from a television show in Houston. When I clicked on “More Information” I was just taken to another page that produced the same PR rhetoric that is displayed on the bottle and no new data.

I used this dressing on my salads for several lunches. I applaud Walden Farms for producing dressings that contain no calories, fat, or sugars and I don’t want to be too hard on them. They sell several other dressings and I can only hope that their taste is bolder than this one. I am anxious to try the different flavors but for now I’m not in any hurry to use the Honey Dijon Vinaigrette again.

Taste Rating = 3 bottles

Overall Rating = 3 bottles

Style Category = Honey Mustard

Fat Category = fat free

Calorie Category = no calorie

Nutritional Category = none

Sodium Category = med